The remaining American Idol finalists delivered a strong set of performances for Tuesday’s Rat Pack theme night, and Adam Lambert, the most popular contender this season, picked “Feeling Good” as his song choice. Jamie Foxx, a stylish singer himself, played mentor tonight.

Randy said it was “a little theatrical and drama filled,” but Simon pointed out that was similar to critiquing a cow for mooing. Kara says, “You are shocking and over the top in a good way…craziness!” Paula praised yet another Adam performance, telling the 27-year-old theater actor that each week “it’s like watching the Olympics and you’re our Michael Phelps.”

Here’s the video of Adam Lambert signing “Feeling Good” on American Idol’s Rat Pack night.